The exclusion of women from the priesthood

Published: Thursday August 20, 2009

Sir:

"Armenian Church ordains 27 men to the priesthood" (Armenian Reporter, August 1, 2009), and not a single woman?

For sure there must be some Armenian women who have the desire and are qualified to be priests, probably more than their male counterparts. There is no sound theological reason for the exclusion of women from the priesthood. The worldwide Christian Church, in all its current varieties, would most likely not have come into existence if not for the dedication of the the three women at the "empty tomb" and the subsequent efforts of Saul/Paul of Tarsus.

I am also amazed at the dedication and support that Armenian women continue to provide to an institution that excludes them from its most important functions. Will they remain the silent majority?


Very truly yours,
Simon Y. Balian
New York, N.Y.

The writer, an attorney, obtained a graduate degree in theology before attending law school.

Send to a friend

To (e-mail address):


Your Name:


Message:


Printer-Friendly

View Comments (3)
  • READ ALL COMMENTS
  • POST A COMMENT
Unprecedented

I would ask Khorenh if such an unprecedented number might have happened sooner if the women who were called to be priests were allowed? I do not see a negative spin being placed on this event, merely a question being raised related to it. He has every right to raise the question as the women of the 1860s would have the right to point out that their sex was not allowed to take part in the election of President Lincoln, nor of any other president for decades to come. Why women could not vote in America or run for president is a natural question which accompanies this auspicious event. To pose it does not take away from the greatness of Lincoln or the presidency in itself. This kind of shouting down at those who would bring up this subject is reminiscent of the very thing I wrote about in my message here "Silenced not silent majority".

By Vartan at August 27, 2009

How Sad

I actually feel sorry for Mr. Balian. If all he can see in this great story about the unprecedented ordination of 27 new clergymen in the Armenian Church is the fact that women are denied the holy orders, then it is clearly evident why it is best for everyone that he is no longer a priest himself. Our nation has not witnessed an event like this for perhaps 100 years, and yet Mr. Balian finds a way to put a negative spin on it. Now that’s impressive indeed.

By khorenh at August 27, 2009

Silenced not silent majority

Women are not the silent majority. They are the silenced majority. And that is the only choice they have: membership in the church at the cost of silence, or exclusion as the reward for disagreement or questioning the status quo.

By Vartan at August 20, 2009

Please register to comment on this article

Already a user?


Presidents of Armenia (left) and France Serge Sargsyan and Nicolas Sarkozy pose outside the presidential palace in Paris. Armenian President's office

French President thanked for "consistency" on Armenian Genocide

Armenia and France exchanged traditional expressions of mutual amity between two countries, as their presidents met in Paris on March 10. And lately, the friendship has expanded into more concrete areas of cooperation - economics and defense.